When choosing a gym, a few names pop up as frequently as Planet Fitness. See Planet Fitness Reddit reviews: real gym-goers are saying.
Known for its budget-friendly memberships and non-intimidating atmosphere, the brand has carved a niche for itself in the fitness industry.
Planet Fitness Reddit Reviews: Real Gym-Goers Are Saying
But what's the real experience like? We dug through hundreds of Reddit reviews and forum discussions to uncover what actual gym-goers are saying.
Spoiler: It mixes praise, criticism, and passionate opinions.
The Good: Affordability, Accessibility, and a Judgment-Free Zone
Super Affordable for Beginners
One of the most consistent praises across Reddit threads is the price point. With memberships starting at just $10/month, it’s hard to beat.
Redditor u/liftingforpizza writes:
“I pay $10 a month and have access to enough equipment to do a full-body workout. I’m not a bodybuilder, just trying to stay healthy, so it’s perfect.”
Many users mention that the $22.99/month Black Card membership is a great deal too — offering perks like tanning beds, massage chairs, guest privileges, and access to any Planet Fitness nationwide.
Beginner-Friendly and Welcoming
Another theme that comes up is the “Judgment Free Zone” ethos. For those new to fitness, that welcoming environment can be a game-changer.
Redditor u/fitnessnoob121 shares:
“I was super anxious about going to the gym for the first time, but the vibe at Planet Fitness was honestly chill. Nobody’s there flexing or showing off.”
The laid-back vibe attracts people of all ages and body types, which makes many first-timers feel more comfortable than they might at a hardcore weightlifting gym.
Clean Facilities and Plenty of Equipment
Multiple Redditors have pointed out that their local PF locations are clean, well-lit, and have plenty of cardio machines. While peak hours can still be busy, most say they rarely have to wait long — especially for treadmills or ellipticals.
u/cardiosavage notes:
“My PF is always spotless. Staff are constantly wiping things down, especially post-COVID.”
The Mixed Bag: Equipment and the “Lunk Alarm”
Great for Cardio, Okay for Strength Training
If you’re into lifting heavy or need access to Olympic platforms, Planet Fitness might not cut it.
Redditor u/barbell_bill writes:
“It’s fine if you’re a beginner doing dumbbell work or machines. But no squat racks, no deadlifting. That’s a dealbreaker for me.”
That’s a recurring theme — PF is great for basic strength training using Smith machines and free weights (dumbbells up to 75 lbs), but it’s not meant for serious powerlifters or bodybuilders.
That said, for people just looking to get in shape, many Redditors insist it’s more than enough.
The Infamous Lunk Alarm
Possibly the most polarizing part of the Planet Fitness brand is the “Lunk Alarm.” It's a siren that staff can activate if someone is grunting, dropping weights, or behaving in an intimidating way.
Some love it for keeping the environment chill. Others… not so much.
u/deadliftingdad says:
“The Lunk Alarm is overkill. I get that they want to avoid the ‘gym bro’ vibe, but sometimes you’re just working hard. That shouldn’t be punished.”
Others have noted it’s rarely used — more of a gimmick than a daily occurrence.
The Not-So-Great: Limited Serious Lifting and Staff Experience
Not for Hardcore Lifters
As mentioned above, PF doesn't cater to people who need things like power racks, bumper plates, or serious barbell training.
u/ironaddict42 shares:
“If you're serious about lifting or training for strength, you'll outgrow Planet Fitness fast.”
Even those doing CrossFit-style routines or Olympic lifts find the limitations too much to work around. If you're looking for a more athletic or functional training environment, Planet Fitness might fall short.
Staff Varies by Location
Reddit users frequently point out that your experience heavily depends on the specific location. While some gyms have friendly, helpful staff, others are reported to be disengaged or poorly trained.
u/gymratgeo writes:
“My PF is awesome — clean, helpful staff, great equipment. My friend’s location? Total opposite. Lazy workers and no management.”
That inconsistency is something to keep in mind. Always check Google or Yelp reviews for your specific location, not just the brand as a whole.
Bonus Mentions from Redditors
Surprisingly Good Showers and Locker Rooms
Several users mention the cleanliness and spaciousness of locker rooms, especially for a budget gym. One user even joked:
“The showers are cleaner than my own bathroom at home.”
Guest Pass = Free Gym Buddy
With the Black Card membership, many take advantage of the guest pass feature to bring friends or family. That’s a big win for motivation.
No Contracts (But Read the Fine Print)
PF advertises "no contracts," but Redditors advise reading the cancellation policy closely. Some report difficulty canceling or hidden fees if you don't do it in person.
So, Should You Join Planet Fitness?
TL;DR – Here’s what Redditors generally agree on:
Pros Cons
Affordable pricing No heavy lifting/power racks
Great for beginners Lunk alarm can be annoying
Clean and well-maintained Staff varies by location
Plenty of cardio equipment Might not suit advanced lifters
Guest privileges with Black Card Limited free weight options
If you're a beginner, looking for a budget-friendly, low-pressure place to get moving, Planet Fitness is a solid choice. If you're aiming to build serious strength, you'll likely hit a wall — or worse, trigger the Lunk Alarm.
The consensus from Reddit? Know your fitness goals, check out your local branch, and don’t let the internet memes decide for you.
Final Thoughts
Planet Fitness Reddit reviews: Real gym-goers say it might not be for everyone, but it's undeniably helped millions of people take their first step into fitness.
Whether you stick with it long-term or use it as a stepping stone, it is important to keep moving and stay consistent.
Have you been to Planet Fitness? Love it or hate it? Let us know your thoughts — or better yet, check out your local PF and see for yourself.
COMMENTS